Florida Man Accused of Mailing Peanut Butter Card to Allergic Woman Over Divorce Grudge

Peanut butter
Getty

A man in Florida was arrested and charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence from an incident stemming from last year after sending a woman with a deadly allergy a card smeared with peanut butter on it.

According to NBC Miami, 68-year-old Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. allegedly sent the victim a greeting card in August 2025 that was deliberately smeared with peanut butter. The woman discovered the “greasy” substance inside her mailbox and soon realized what it was.

After coming into contact with the peanut butter, she immediately broke out in hives and experienced a “tingling sensation in both arms that lasted 6 hours.” Thankfully, the woman is okay, with new information now shedding light on what allegedly prompted Cancellare to send the bizarre and potentially dangerous mail.


Man Sends Friend of Ex-Wife Postage Smeared With Peanut Butter, Tried to Trigger Deadly Reaction

CBS Miami is reporting that 68-year-old Joseph Cancellare sent a woman a greeting card smeared with peanut butter, knowing she was “deathly allegeric” after being unhappy with her alleged role in his divorce.

The outlet reported that the victim, who has not been identified, received the postage, which was described as a “blue envelope that appeared greasy with handwriting she did not recognize,” from Cancellare after arrest reports state that he “largely blamed [redacted] for the divorce.” The victim is identified as Cancellare’s ex-wife’s best friend.

In fact, the victim revealed that Cancellare “absolutely know about her allergy as the couples went to dinner countless times in which [redacted] had to be mindful of accidentally coming into contact with peanuts.” They also shared that he “took precautions to avoid her being exposed,” when he visited her home.

Cancellare was arrested and is now facing charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence.


How Police Identified Cancellare As the Culprit

Peanut butter
GettyPeanut butter is seen on a shelf in a Target store on July 08, 2022 in Houston, Texas.

According to CBS News, Cancellare used a fake name and return address on the letter, but investigators were able to track down Cancellare as the culprit through the postage stamps on the envelope.

According to the arrest report, they worked with the Postal Inspector, who helped trace U.S. Forever stamps attached to the envelope to a self-service kiosk at a Davie Post Office. “Joseph drove to a USPS store in a different city than where he lived. He walked in and continued to wear his sunglasses inside the business in an attempt to disguise his identity,” police shared in their report.

The stamps had a 15-digit code that helped identify that they were purchased with a Visa card that belonged to Cancellare. Investigators also showed the victim photos of the person purchasing the stamps at the kiosk, and she identified the man as Cancellare. In fact, many other people identified him in the photographs, including a close friend who played in a band with him.

0 Comments

Florida Man Accused of Mailing Peanut Butter Card to Allergic Woman Over Divorce Grudge

Notify of
0 Comments
Subscribe
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x