
At the time, in 2004, Susan Smith’s murder cases was infamous, and it caused national headlines throughout the U.S. The young mother strapped her two young kids into car seats and then, horrifically, allowed the car to roll into a lake, drowning them. Eventually, she confessed.
She initially falsely blamed a fictional black carjacker, giving the case a disturbing overlay of race, and at first David believed her story, appearing at press conferences at her side. And then it unraveled. Susan was tried and convicted and has been in prison ever since. Now, on November 19, Smith will have a chance at parole and one man is trying to stand in the prison door, figuratively speaking. Her former husband, David Smith.
In advance of the parole hearing, David spoke with CNN about his wishes. His sons, Alex and Michael, would be in their 30s today. You can see Smith’s current prison photo below. Her prison record shows a number of infractions. This is the second time she will be eligible for parole, according to Fox News. The crime happened in South Carolina, and the kids were 14-month-old Alex and 3-year-old Michael.
David Smith Says He Wants Susan Smith to ‘Stay in Prison Until He Dies’

David Smith is definitive. He doesn’t want Susan to ever see freedom again.
“It’s been hard, hard,” he says. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies.”
In an emotional interview, David said he wants Susan Smith to stay in prison. He is remarried to wife Tiffany. “People ask me, ‘How old would they be today?’ I don’t know. I can’t process that, because to me, they’ll always be 3 (years) and 14 months,” he told CNN.
To This Day, David Smith Struggles to Figure Out the Motive
To this day, he told CNN that he doesn’t understand why she did it. “They didn’t do anything wrong,” he says. “They weren’t even old enough to be held accountable in God’s eyes for making mistakes.”
He wants the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons in Columbia to reject her bid for parole, which they also did last time.
“I want them to look at it … through my eyes,” he told CNN. “It’s important for me to remind the parole board that it may be 32 years, but for me it’s still like yesterday. Thirty-two years hasn’t changed the heartache.”
According to Time Magazine, at her trial, Smith’s defense attorney argued she “was psychologically destabilized by a lifetime of betrayals,” including her father’s suicide and sexual abuse. The prosecution portrayed Smith’s “murderous act as the culmination of a life of deceit and manipulation. In reality, both characterizations may contain elements of truth,” Time reported. Susan was having an affair with a man who broke it off in a letter, stating in part that he didn’t want the responsibilities of helping raise her children, Time reported.

Notorious Child Killer Susan Smith’s Former Husband, David, Speaks Out Before Parole Hearing